Home »
Jazz Articles » Album Review » Christy Doran’s May 95 Sextet: Same But Different
Curse or blessing? A festival handing a musician carte blanche for a one-off adventure sounds liberating, but the allure of artistic freedom can be tempered by pressure: what if the personalities do not gel? What if it bombs?
Christy Doran, the Ireland-born Lucerne-based guitarist, has never been one to dodge a challenge. His entire career has been marked by adventure and innovation. From jazz-rock fusioneers OM in the early ’70s to his later groups New Bag, Sound Fountain, and Morpheus Trance, Doran has consistently blurred the lines between jazz, rock and free improvisation.
His experimental folk collaboration with Chinese pipa player Yang Jing on No. 9 (Leo Records, 2013) and the free- soundscaping outing with Japanese pianist
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Izumi Kimura on Glacial Voyage (Between The Lines, 2025) are just two salient examples from an extensive discography that speak to his willingness to throw caution to the wind.
So when the Schaffhausen Jazz Festival invited Doran to put together a special project for its 1995 edition, he did not hold back, assembling a two-horn, two-drummer electric ensemble with a license to play on the edge. Saxophonist
Urs Leimgruber
saxophone, soprano
b.1952
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Urs Leimgruber and drummer
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Fredy Studerold sparring partners from OMare joined by trumpeter
Herb Robertson
trumpet
b.1951
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Herb Robertson, drummer ”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Jim Meneses and electric bassist
Kevin Bruce Harris
bass, electric
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Kevin Bruce Harris. This 90-minute recording, seeing the light of day for the first time, captures a sextet in blistering form.
Seven compositions range from just under 10 minutes to 23 minutes. The 17-minute “Incognito” is split over two sides of this double vinyl releasea slight inconvenience that the streaming option sidesteps. Initially, comparison to
Ornette Coleman
saxophone, alto
1930 – 2015
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Ornette Coleman‘s Prime Time groups is temptingnot least for the dual drummers and rhythmic complexities. The strong riffs, Leimgruber’s and Robertson’s unison motifs and the free-wheeling improvisations also echo Coleman’s late ’70s ensembles. This is especially true on the free-spirited “Next,” which opens the set. Yet Doran’s blueprint has more formal cohesion and a steadier rhythmic keel. If anything, Doran’s sextet is perhaps closer in spirit to the pulsating jazz-rock of
Miles Davis
trumpet
1926 – 1991
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Miles Davis‘s Jack Johnson (Columbia, 1971).
That Davis soundtrackto the film about Black boxing world champion Jack Johnsonfeatured some of the most impassioned soloing of Davis, his guitarist
John McLaughlin
guitar
b.1942
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>John McLaughlin, and soprano saxophonist
Steve Grossman
saxophone
1951 – 2020
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Steve Grossman. The same could be said of Doran, Leimgruber and Robertson on Same But Different Leimgruber’s soprano spits fire on the epic, groove-centric “Instinct,” which Doran single-handedly steers into post-
Jimi Hendrix
guitar, electric
1942 – 1970
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Jimi Hendrix psychedelic overdrive via his pedal board. “New Outline-Shorter Cut,” by contrast, is a simmering stew of abstract free improvisations; devoid of conventional soloing, its coiled tensions harbor a peculiar drama of dark hues.
The episodic “Incognito” shifts from jam-band groove to solo free-improvisation and back again. Along the way there are solos of striking contrast. First Robertson, then Leimgrubersounding like Korean saxophone shaman
Kang Tae Hwan
saxophone, alto
”
data-original-title=”” title=””>Kang Tae Hwanfollowed by the irrepressible Doran, who delivers a spluttering, flamethrower of a solo. The two drummers have the stage to themselves for four thunderous minutes on the title track before a high-tempo ensemble passage of a knotty weave so typical of Doran. This in turn cedes ground to a visceral, almost animalistic trumpet-and-saxophone exchange. A bass, drum and guitar passage of gentler design ambles towards a fade-out that suggests further twists and turns did not make the final cut.
Debates about vinyl sound quality versus digital compression, or about edited cuts versus the integrity of complete, uninterrupted recordings, will likely abound. But any such arguments should not detract from what is a highly engaging concert performance. The bruising rhythmic intensity and searing solos are the main takeaways, but there is much more under the hood of Doran’s May 95 sextet. Same But Different takes its place in Doran’s discography as one of his most potent live recordings.
“>
Track Listing
Next; Twists and Turns; Instinct; New Outline-Shorter Cuts; Incognito; Same But Different.
Personnel
Additional Instrumentation
Christy Doran: devices; Fredy Studer: percussion; Jim Meneses: percussion; Urs Leimgruber: tenor saxophone.
Album information
Title: Same But Different
| Year Released: 2025
| Record Label: Unit Records
Tags
PREVIOUS / NEXT
Support All About Jazz
All About Jazz has been a pillar of jazz since 1995, championing it as an art form and, more importantly, supporting the musicians who make it. Our enduring commitment has made “AAJ” one of the most culturally important websites of its kind, read by hundreds of thousands of fans, musicians and industry figures every month.
Go Ad Free!
To maintain our platform while developing new means to foster jazz discovery and connectivity, we need your help. You can become a sustaining member for as little as $20 and in return, we’ll immediately hide those pesky ads plus provide access to future articles for a full year. This winning combination vastly improves your AAJ experience and allow us to vigorously build on the pioneering work we first started in 1995. So enjoy an ad-free AAJ experience and help us remain a positive beacon for jazz by making a donation today.